Advanced Composition 8.1: Academically Adrift (2)

Today’s plan:

  • Reading Questions
  • Discussion

Reading Questions

Working in paris of two, I will ask you to answer the following questions. Please tie your answers to specific page numbers. We will then share answers.

Chapter Two: Origins and Trajectories

  • Approximately what percentage of students fail to demonstrate significant gains in critical thinking, complex reasoning, and writing skills?
  • How does this chapter challenge “boot strap” arguments? How does it support boot strap arguments?
  • Ultimately, what do the authors identify as the “key factor” shaping growth rates in critical thinking, complex reasoning, and writing skills?
  • What do these authors identify as the social/political impact of these findings?

Chapter Three: Pathways Through College Adrift

  • What is a “credentialist collegiate orientation”? How might you characterize Arum and Roska’s feelings toward such an approach?
  • What is a major factor in faculty-student interaction?
  • What two criteria do Arum and Roksa use to identify “rigorous curriculum”?
  • Choice of major: more rational decision or directionless drift?
  • What particular majors struggle with the CLA objectives? Which excel? [critical thinking, complex reasoning, writing skills]
  • Chapter Four: Channeling Students’ Energies Toward Learning

    • What is critical to students “learning more”?
    • What is *surprisingly* important to student improvement?
    • What is the ultimate scarce resource?
    • What do students spend a majority of their time on?
    • What are two things students can do to learn more?
    • What can institutions do to foster learning?

    Chapter 5 Notes

    The opening analogy seems painfully accurate (121).

    Sobering statistics on 123.

    A damning conclusion: 125.

    Improving student preparation: 126 (hearing echoes of Dewey in Damon)

    Improving administrators: 127, 129 (setting the stage for Giroux?)

    Improving curriculum: 131, Changing Faculty focus: 134

    Worth reading: “Facilitating Learning, Not Just Persistence” (pages 135-136)

    Final thought: putting your money where your mouth is, page 141

    Homework

    Read the introduction to Giroux’s Neoliberalism’s War….

    Print Friendly, PDF & Email
    This entry was posted in education, rhetoric, teaching and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.